Are We Losers????

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

An angry Bengali posted following Youtube video as a video comment to one of my videos on Youtube, in addition to naked abuses to Pakistanis especially Punjabis. I can understand Bengalis' anger against Punjabis. We didn't do anything with Bengalis to deserve love. But this video is just too devastating.

I would have been ferociously angry, had someone else given these comments about my country. But this video is making me cry, you know why? The comments given about Pakistan have been made by a daughter of this country. She looks like a young budding talent of my country who has no pride for being a Pakistani, who has utmost contempt for the people and for the country itself. Sixty two years of existence and a mind boggling graph of material development, but we could not produce a proud youth! Do we still care to ask ourselves, why? I don't think. Because I'm sure, in response to this small piece, there will be at least a dozen comments denying all this and claiming that the girl in this video is an exception and we have a progeny full of national pride!

My worry would not end here though. Presence of even one kid like this, concerns me a lot. I can't blame the curriculum. As a student of history and avid reader of history curricula taught in Pakistan, I know that authors of our curricula decided to distort the history to the fullest, in a bid to induce certain kind of "nationalism" among our generations. The practice dates back to the earliest years of country's existence. This nationalism coupled with a disproportionate emphasis on "Nazria-e-Pakistan" (Ideology of Pakistan) has produced all of us. The decadence in our intellectual competencies as well as our sense of responsibility towards and pride about our country, during all these decades is too obvious to miss.

One thing seems clear, the curriculum with all that ado about our self righteous ideology parade and false sense of induced nationalism, both have proven fruitless. Distortion never helps, especially when it is done with as sacred a thing as history. Just look at the product of this curriculum. A progeny that is shy of calling itself a Pakistani, who thinks Pakistanis are losers, who thinks Urdu as a non-cool language and who thinks this language and this dress can't win them a status.

Do we still see where we've been wrong? Are we willing to see the evil within? Are we committed to overcome it? Its in our own hands. Why don't we take things in our own hands now? Why to put it in politicians' hands to teach our kids a faith in themselves and a pride in their nationhood? Let's not take it against English - the language of power. But let's not make it first language of our children. Let's not forget who we are. And let's tell our kids honestly, who we are! And let's remind them that Pakistanis are definitely not losers!




Bookmark and Share

5 comments:

shobz October 27, 2009 at 2:32 AM  

this poor girl is suffering from some sort of inferiority complex. There was no need for her to diss Pakistan and to act like a total airhead just so that she could get her 15 minutes of fame. She was willing to sink so low in order to get some fame. One should be proud of his/her identity as that is what distinguishes us from the rest of the bunch.

Marvi Sirmed October 27, 2009 at 2:49 AM  

Absolutely! But a painful fact is, that we have so many young people around us, who are close to her if not exactly like her. In that, I really can't blame anyone. It us. We, the people from a generation earlier, who could not give anything to these people.

Anonymous,  October 27, 2009 at 6:00 AM  

I wish the person interviewing her would have been a little decent. The way he had been shouting and talking was enough for any young person to hate the country of his origin.

Anonymous,  October 27, 2009 at 12:20 PM  

well, she is definately suffering from complex, we r lot better then the others, off course there r some problems but on the base of these problem which r actually due to our politicians n Govt: who has lack of interest towards solving the problem, their main purpose is to get wealthy and then get lost of here. Anywayz u r absolutely wrong Marvi Sirmed, we have only few youngsters who has this kind of mentality or think like that, beinag a nation u have seen our unity on 14th August, 2009. Being a muslim we should not be disappointed, Inshallah i strongly believe that if we will b alive, we will c a shining Pakistna soon. The girl in this video has forgotton her own values being a muslim, she is eating here, living here and talking like..........just leave it, just on the base of this video we can not judge pakistani youth. the one n only Allah who is creator of every thing n he always do anything for our betterment, he knows better then all of us and he knows exectly wat he is doing and we can never immagine wat is behid his will, soo wait n b patient and have good hope

Anonymous,  October 27, 2009 at 9:58 PM  

I favour these comments.
I wish the person interviewing her would have been a little decent. The way he had been shouting and talking was enough for any young person to hate the country of his origin.

Post a Comment

About This Blog

Blog Archive

  © Blogger template Foam by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP